Posts

The Freedom No One Can Take Away

 

 

یہ مضمون اردو میں پڑھیں

Viktor Frankl, the Austrian neurologist and psychiatrist who survived the horrors of Nazi concentration camps, once expressed a timeless truth: everything can be taken away from a person—health, wealth, relationships, possessions—but one freedom always remains: the freedom to choose one’s response.

This insight was not a philosophical idea formed in a comfortable armchair; it was uncovered through the toughest human experiences. Frankl spent three years in concentration camps, dealing with starvation, humiliation, forced labor, and the constant threat of death. Every morning, he woke up uncertain if he would make it through the day, and each night, he went to sleep not knowing if he would see the sunrise. Still, amidst this daily fight with mortality, he learned that even when everything was taken away, there was one thing his captors could not take—his inner freedom.

Freedom in the Midst of Suffering

Frankl noted that prisoners reacted differently to the same brutality. Some gave in to despair, others became bitter, while a few kept their dignity and compassion. The difference wasn’t in the circumstances — which were equally harsh for everyone — but in how they responded.

This is where Frankl’s discovery shines:

  • You may not control what happens to you.
  • You may not control how others treat you.
  • You may not control illness, loss, or tragedy.

But you can always control how you choose to respond.

Think about two people who unexpectedly lose their jobs.

  • The first person falls into despair, blames others, and sinks into hopelessness.
  • The second experiences the same pain but chooses to view it as a chance to re-evaluate life, improve skills, or even follow a long-neglected passion.

The event remains the same—losing a job. But the result varies greatly depending on how you respond.

Small Daily Illustrations

This principle is not limited to extreme cases like concentration camps or devastating losses. It applies to our everyday lives.

  • When someone cuts us off in traffic, do we get angry or take a deep breath and keep going?
  • When a family member speaks harshly, should we retaliate right away or pause and respond calmly?
  • When plans fall apart, do we drown in self-pity or see the setback as a lesson?

In each situation, our well-being is influenced more by how we respond than by what actually happens.

An Anecdote of Perspective

A teacher once poured a glass of water halfway and asked the class, “What do you see?” Some said, “Half empty.” Others said, “Half full.” He smiled and said, “Both are correct. But remember, the choice of which one you see determines not just your mood today but also your future tomorrow.”

Frankl’s lesson is the same: we cannot alter the facts, but we can always change how we see and respond to them.

Remember

  1. Response is Power – It is the one area of freedom no one can breach.
  2. Response is Responsibility – With this freedom comes accountability; we can’t always blame circumstances or others.
  3. Response Shapes Character – Each time we select our response, we are shaping who we become.

A Takeaway for Life

The world may take away many things from us. We might face illness, rejection, failure, or even severe injustice. But as long as we are alive, we hold within us the sacred space of choice. That space—our ability to respond—is the source of dignity, resilience, and purpose.

As Frankl understood in the bleakest moments: “They can take everything from me, but they cannot take my response. That remains mine, and mine alone.”

For Reflection:

Recall a recent situation where you reacted impulsively. If you had taken a moment to pause, what different response could you have chosen? How might it have affected the outcome for you and others?

Life often places us at crossroads where patience and action seem to pull us in opposite directions. A deal falls through unfairly, someone mistreats us, or a friend takes advantage of our silence. In those moments, the mind wrestles with a familiar question: Should I just accept this quietly, or should I speak up and claim my right?

The Two Extremes We Inherit

From childhood, many of us are shaped by the attitudes of the families and cultures we grow up in. Some grow up with the idea that they must simply accept whatever happens—believing that raising a voice is arrogance, ingratitude, and resistance to God’s will. Others are taught the opposite: that if they do not strike back harder than they were struck, they will be seen as weak and taken advantage of.

Neither extreme truly helps us. Silence in the face of injustice holds us back from being morally responsible, while retaliation may win a momentary victory but often escalates conflict and leaves us hardened.

The middle way—balancing patience with assertiveness—requires inner strength. It is neither passive nor aggressive. It is choosing to stay calm inside while still standing up firmly for what is fair.

The Misunderstood “Acceptance”

This balance begins with a clearer understanding of acceptance. Accepting reality does not mean giving up responsibility. There is a difference between surrendering bitterness inside and surrendering responsibility outside.

For example, if someone is wronged in a financial matter, patience would mean not letting anger consume them. Assertiveness would mean pursuing a fair resolution calmly and without malice. Acceptance, then, is not resignation. It is clarity: “This happened, and now I must respond wisely.”

Everyday Scenarios

  • At Work: An employer delays paying wages. Patience means avoiding gossip or resentment. Assertiveness means calmly asking for what is due, following up, and not letting the issue slide.
  • In Family: A sibling denies you a fair share of inheritance. Patience means not poisoning the relationship with grudges. Assertiveness means taking the matter to resolution through the right channels.
  • In Community Life: Corruption or unfair treatment occurs in the neighborhood. Patience means resisting despair. Assertiveness means joining with others to challenge what is wrong and promote fairness.

Each of these examples shows that patience is an inner discipline, while assertiveness is an outward responsibility. One without the other leaves us lopsided.

Inner Conversations

Much of this balance is shaped by the dialogue we carry inside. When something unfair happens, the first thought might be: “Why me? This is so unjust.” That thought can easily spiral into helplessness or anger.

But if we reframe it—“I can respond without losing my dignity. I can seek fairness without becoming unfair myself.”—The situation begins to look different. Our response becomes a choice, not a reaction.

A Story from Everyday Life

Imagine a woman who pays for a service but receives poor treatment in return. She could choose anger, demanding loudly and shaming the provider. She could also choose silence, swallowing the loss and telling herself to forget. But there is a third way: to remain composed, express the problem clearly, and insist on a solution. She keeps her self-respect without damaging the other person’s dignity.

This is the sweet spot where patience and assertiveness meet.

Why It Matters

We often think of patience as inaction and assertiveness as aggression. In truth, both are about strength. Patience is the strength over one’s own emotions. Assertiveness is a strength in the face of others’ actions. Together, they allow us to respond wisely—without being ruled by fear, anger, or ego.

When we reject both resignation and retaliation, we discover that real dignity lies not in silence or in shouting, but in speaking with calm firmness.

Conclusion

The art of living well is learning when to bow in patience and when to rise in assertiveness. To suffer wrongs silently is not strength, and to demand justice harshly is not wisdom. Real strength lies in combining the two: a calm heart that endures, and a steady voice that speaks.

This balance prevents us from shrinking into helplessness or hardening into bitterness. It helps us remain whole—grateful in ease, steadfast in hardship, and responsible in justice.